Friday, 11 June 2010

WHAT IS THE POLITICAL NATURE OF THE EDL?

From Luton to Tel Aviv –

the trajectory of imperialistic fraternity


By Dan Renwick for Sons of Malcolm


"To label the EDL and ZF "racist" is too crude. They are imperialists committed to the perpetuation of Orientalism and European hegemony. The saddest thing about both movements however is how divorced they are from reality. They are products of deceit; a lie that argues that the social alignments of liberalism are conceived on the basis of moral values and not the dogma of the market."


This week we witnessed the conjunction of the English Defence League (EDL) and the Zionist federation (ZF) who united for a rally in support of Israel's brutal raid on the Freedom Flotilla. Despite both the BBC and The Guardian covering the rise of the EDL of late, both failed to cover the story of this troublesome matching.

The EDL are crudely referred to as a “far-right organisation”. They were formed in Luton following Muslims challenging British soldiers returning from their conquests in Afghanistan with placards with messages like "murderers". In response a group of "concerned citizens" attacked the demonstrators and rampaged around Luton. When national outrage was felt due to this "attack on the pride of British heroes”, the campaign became national and in their wisdom they called it the English Defence League, excluding Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales from their name, while planning marches in all UK major cities.


What the EDL have mobilised to support are the values of English/British society which are "under attack" from the ever elusive “Sharia”. While some may wish to label them akin to the BNP, their genealogy is not so simple; I trace their rhetoric to Blair more than Mosley. In the simplest possible terms, they have domesticated the foreign policy of the West. What Blair attacked Afghanistan for are the same reasons the EDL are planning to attack Bradford and Tower Hamlets. Their reasoning is “humanitarian”: Islam in its political form “Islamism” subjugates women, enshrines patriarchy, encourages violence, is homophobic and is diametrically opposed to liberalism and representative democracy – it therefore must be eradicated from within Britain.

The EDL believe themselves to be bastions of toleration; defence structures guarding the moral nucleus that so typifies European thought. They not only grossly misunderstand the notion of toleration, immortalised with Voltaire's "I may not like what you say, but I shall fight to the death for your right to say it" (which, unfortunately for them, includes political Islam) - they also strongly misunderstand the basis of the faith they oppose; swallowing hook, line and sinker the propaganda that justified a war of political strategy fought under the guise of "moral values". The source of the EDL's political venom derives solely from the post 9/11 world where "Muslim" and "terrorist" became synonyms. It is only with this point of clarification in mind that the EDL's affinity Zionism can be understood. Israel are the "civilising force" in the Middle-East and need support in their "humanitarian" moral conquest to turn those misguided "Islamists" into liberals. At the heart of both movements thinking is the white man's burden of bringing "civilisation" to the world through uncivilised means. Both the EDL and the Zionists accept and endorse violence to subjugate and sedate the communities they fear.


To label the EDL and ZF "racist" is too crude. They are imperialists committed to the perpetuation of Orientalism and European hegemony. The saddest thing about both movements however is how divorced they are from reality. They are products of deceit; a lie that argues that the social alignments of liberalism are conceived on the basis of moral values and not the dogma of the market. They valorise liberal democracy missing its oligarchic nature. Their moral universality knows no bounds, unless of course you are Muslim/Arab/"Paki". Principles of exclusion are embedded within both outlooks - there is an enemy within and without that needs to be expunged - only then can a moral foreign policy and domestic society come into fruition.

Their fear of the other derives from a fictious existential threat, paranoia being their greatest recruitment technique. Both movements are the outcome of a nationalistic lie that was told to justify the appropriation of an other's resources. For the Zionists, the Arabs became the evil villains who have a natural propensity to replicate Hitler. For the EDL the Taliban are the voicebox of all Muslims, those who accept Liberal values only do so to assimilate. When the Caliphate is re-established the essentialism to the Arab/South Asian skin colour will spark a shift in mind state that will turn great British citizens into jihadi Islamists. Both movements can be traced to an ideology that propagates fear in order to justify aggression.

One may want to make this argument about the lack of political acumen in the Zionist movement, if they believe they can align with the far-right and not accept the anti-Semitism that they are killing Palestinians to eradicate. However, this is too reliant upon a conception of the right that is divorced from the ideology of our times and completely misses the essence of Zionism; colonialism. This alliance is the logical outcome of a project of imperialism and has been defended as "left wing" by the likes of Nick Cohen and Tony Blair. The right we now face talk a completely different discourse; a post-modern, euphemistic language of libertarianism and morality. "Scratch the EDL find the BNP" may be true to some of the divisions, like Stoke, but to assume homogeneity nationally is problematic and lazy. Given the complete lack of engagement of the traditional left with this topic, and the imminent threat of a repeat of the riots of 2001 in Bradford and Tower Hamlets - we have to ask - can we really afford for this laziness to continue?


==============================

Dan Renwick can be contacted at:

danielrenwick@gmail.com


9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Black muslims history in America,
From to be a slave to prey to a dead slave owner "prophet" mohammed. Is not that sick?
From Sweden.
If muslims kill Sweden artists is it self defense to kill muslims?
Help to cure and help muslim children from islam.
Send this info to muslim childrens home page,
When "prophet" mohammed was 50 he marry a 9 year old child,
So he was a fucking pedophile and a slave owner.
Watch and read
http://www.mohammedt-shirt.com
it´s not mine ip nr

Sukant Chandan said...

oh my. more crazies.

get some humanity before your heart turns completely black.

Matthew Joseph Johnson said...

Good to see a more nuanced analysis of the EDL. 'Far right' is too easily dismissed - as a newer movement they can't be dealt with in such simple terms.

nasser mashadi said...

The BNP and EDL
Feature by Martin Smith, March 2010

Socialist Review March 2010

free on line

http://www.socialistreview.org.uk/article.php?articlenumber=11183

A new racist political group is organising on the streets. They call themselves the English Defence League, but who are they and what do they represent? Martin Smith investigates

Alan Lake is a middle aged English businessman. Last September he addressed an anti-Islam conference organised by the racist Sweden Democrats in Malmo. This shady figure told delegates that it was necessary to build an anti-Jihad movement that was "ready to go out onto the street". He also claimed that he and his friends had already begun to build alliances with football supporters.


One month later Lake told a Daily Telegraph journalist, "We are worn out with words. You need to have people on the streets. You have to get the message out." The article went on to claim that Lake was seeking to harness football hooligan "firms" by timing demonstrations to coincide with matches. Lake boasted, "These guys [football hooligans] are prepared to demonstrate, and they are already there because there is a match. This is a dirty, nasty, difficult struggle and you have to work with what is available."


Alan Lake is a key financier of the English Defence League (EDL).

lau-ra said...

his is an awesome article all except for the essence of zionism being colonialism. that isn't exactly true. zionism is a heartfelt wish of jewish people to return to their homeland. if this could be accomplished without taking over, but by living harmoniously within a society that had already been established in the region, it could have been successful.

Anonymous said...

Will there be a new Rihanna naked sex tape? That is what TMZ has been reporting this weekend, after the breakup of her 3 week old boyfriend Matt Kemp, as always with most celebrity breakups the celeb sex tape gets released a short time after, will the Rihanna naked Sex Tape actually be as good as they say? TMZ reports, yes, yes it will
see rihanna naked
Rihanna was born on February 20, 1988, in a county in Barbados called St. Michael. She lived the life of a normal island girl going to Combermere, a top sixth form school, similar to grammar schools in the UK. Rihanna sex tape won a beauty pageant and performed Mariah Carey's "Hero" in a school talent show. Her life changed forever when one of her friends introduced her to Evan Rodgers, a producer from New York who was in Barbados for vacation with his wife, who is a native.
rihanna naked

Anonymous said...

no wonder de never came to see u nor tha help ya...

Anonymous said...

Amiable fill someone in on and this mail helped me alot in my college assignement. Thank you for your information.

Anonymous said...

A wide good physical condition program tailored to an own will undoubtedly core on one or more definitive skills, and on age-[3] or health-related needs such as bone health.[4] Numberless sources[citation needed] also cite loony, social and heartfelt health as an significant purposes of whole fitness. This is over presented in textbooks as a triangle made up of three points, which reproduce solid, nervous, and loony fitness. Physical fitness can also forestall or act towards various long-lived health conditions brought on next to unhealthy lifestyle or aging.[5] Working discernible can also help people snore better. To visit healthy it is important to agree in material activity.
Training

Specific or task-oriented [url=http://www.pella.pl]fitness[/url] is a human being's talents to fulfil in a definite enterprise with a sober expertness: for example, sports or military service. Individual to training prepares athletes to perform wonderfully in their sports.

Examples are:

400 m sprint: in a sprint the athlete requirement be trained to redundant anaerobically all the way through the race.
Marathon: in this what really happened the athlete have to be trained to work aerobically and their endurance ought to be built-up to a maximum.
Multifarious blazing fighters and police officers sustain regular tone testing to draw if they are masterly of the physically demanding tasks required of the job.
Members of the Partnership States Army and Army Governmental Look after have to be skilled to pass the Army Tangible Competence Check-up (APFT).